A married, earning daughter living apart can still claim motor accident compensation, Delhi High Court holds
10 November 2026
In United India Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Savita, a single judge of the Delhi High Court held that every legal representative may claim under Section 166 of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988 without first proving financial dependency. A married daughter, son, spouse or sibling cannot be shut out merely for being married, earning or living separately, the court said; dependency has to be weighed on the facts of each claim instead of through fixed classes of dependants and non-dependants. Where a claimant is only partly dependent, that is to be reflected in the deduction for personal expenses and in how the award is shared, with a wholly dependent claimant taking the larger share. The court declined to follow the practice of treating a non-dependant's claim as a notional loss of estate, holding it inconsistent with the Supreme Court rulings in Sarla Verma and Pranay Sethi. The claimant was the sister of one victim and the daughter of the other, both of whom died in a 2015 accident; she had married in 2002 and lived apart. The awards were raised to ₹14,38,054 and ₹20,20,871.50, each including ₹40,000 towards consortium, with interest at 9 per cent.