No adverse inference from an unfiled return for the accident year, Delhi High Court holds in a comatose claimant's case
10 November 2026
In Bharat Ghai v. Raju Grover, a single judge of the Delhi High Court held that a Motor Accidents Claims Tribunal cannot infer that a victim had no taxable income merely because no income tax return was filed for the year of the accident, since a family cannot be expected to reconstruct those records once the victim is disabled. The claimant, an event manager, has been in a coma since a road accident and was found to have total permanent impairment. The court benchmarked his income by averaging three years of returns, applying the approach in Rashmirekha Tripathy v. Sriram General Insurance, and applied a multiplier of fifteen along with future medical expenses, physiotherapy, nursing and attendant charges. It set aside the deduction made for mediclaim, following New India Assurance v. Dolly Satish Gandhi, and refused loss of consortium on the ground that the head is payable only where the victim has died, as laid down in Pranay Sethi. The award was raised from ₹1,52,76,996 to ₹4,26,09,147, with ₹2,73,32,151 to be deposited within six weeks at interest of 7.5 per cent.
In plain words
MACT Motor Accidents Claims Tribunal — The tribunal that decides claims for compensation arising out of motor accidents.