Constructive res judicata does not bar a claim whose cause of action arose later, the Supreme Court holds
Background
The Supreme Court has held that constructive res judicata does not bar a later claim if the cause of action for that claim had not arisen when the first case was filed. The appellant was a retired employee of the Central Bank of India whose first writ petition had challenged disciplinary proceedings against him. The High Court ordered his reinstatement with consequential benefits in 2007, but his salary arrears were paid only in 2011. The later petition asking for interest on the delayed payment was dismissed on the ground that interest had not been claimed in the earlier petition. The Supreme Court set aside that order of the Punjab and Haryana High Court. The Court held that the bar would apply only if the cause of action for the interest claim had existed when the first petition was filed. The delay in payment gave rise to a fresh cause of action, so the claim for interest could be pursued on its own.
In plain words
Res judicata — The rule that a matter already decided between the same parties cannot be tried again.
Cause of action — The set of facts that gives a person the right to go to court.
Writ petition — A petition to a High Court or the Supreme Court for a constitutional remedy.