National 9 of 9

Stay of a conviction cannot be sought for electoral ambition, the Supreme Court says

The Supreme Court has set out how a court should use its power to stay a conviction while an appeal or a revision is pending. The Court said that a plea to stay a conviction cannot rest only on electoral ambition or on the timing of an election campaign. At the same time the discretion must be used by weighing the damage a conviction does to a person's reputation and dignity against the sanctity of a finding of guilt. The Court held that personal standing, public reputation and human dignity are part of the right to life guaranteed by Article 21. The Court said the loss of that standing while a genuine revision is pending could amount to irreparable prejudice. The power under Section 389 must therefore be used with care, because the years of stigma cannot be repaired if the conviction is set aside later. The Court referred to its earlier judgment in Afjal Ansari for the same approach. In the matter before it the Court kept the convictions of the appellants stayed while their criminal revision petitions are pending in the High Court.

Provision: Section 389 Right relied on: Article 21 Earlier judgment referred to: Afjal Ansari
Why it matters for exams: Article 21 and the power to suspend a sentence pending appeal are standard questions, and this ruling ties the two together.
Kerala PSCUPSC
19 November 2026 Source: LiveLaw

In plain words

Stay of conviction — A court order that suspends the effect of a conviction while an appeal or revision is heard.

Revision — A higher court's re-examination of a lower court's order.

On a phone, swipe left or right to move between stories.